Downside verse the Upside

It may just be my natural bias, but it seems the “anti-gold bugs” have more animosity and emotion when expressing their views on gold then the gold bugs have in their excitement for the yellow metal. And there is absolutely nothing wrong with being bearish on gold at present time. Especially as the trend following the undeniable strength of the US dollar and chatter of the US Federal Reserve hiking interest rates gives little reason or evidence to go against consensus. But the “anti-gold bugs” are wrong to rejoice or point out the fact that gold has failed to rally when fundamentals should suggest otherwise. That is simply incorrect.

The most common examples or better, what have been misconceptions of the failed rallies in gold in recent weeks are the China stock market turmoil and fears of a Grexit, or Greece exiting the Euro currency. We’ll examine both.

There are still reasons to be worried about the issues in financial markets in China, despite being absent from the headlines this past week. The list of measures that were taken to support their market makes it essentially improbable for them to retreat any further. At one point in recent weeks, half the publicly traded companies on the Shanghai and Shenzhen exchange were halted from trading for multiple days. China’s central bank was directly financing a crown corporation to actively buy equities. Shareholders with greater than 5 per cent ownership of any public company are banned from selling for six months. Derivative markets and short selling have been banned. The list goes on. To suggest that financial instability in China generates demand for gold implies liquidity, which is non-existent.

Story number two is Greece. And this is more a story that fits into the greater trend in financial markets, which is the slow decline of the euro. In this kind of economic setting money has been gravitating towards the US dollar. The European Central Bank is extremely active in European debt markets, and has a higher probability of becoming more accommodative than less. The US is getting more and more likely to raise interest rates come September. This world is being weighed on a relative basis and although gold bugs, perhaps to a fault, see too many problems ahead for the US economy, compared to the Eurozone or elsewhere in the world, its clear why capital is headed towards the United States for the time being.

The question then, is where that leaves us with gold. It’s been a while since I’ve pounded the table and made a bullish case for precious metals. This still might not be it. I believe in accumulation and I believe in allocating a small percentage of your portfolio to physical gold as insurance. Especially in a world that is so tied currently to decoupling with the US economy, gold is not only the natural hedge, but the perfect hedge.

The other point to make is how much downside a person can be comfortable with. Investing in physical metal as a hedge against geopolitical uncertainty and US dollar instability is one reason. But if gold has a floor of 950 or 1000 USD per ounce, is it worth risking that capital to be invested if, or when this market turns.

Capital Controls: The Game Changer

Make no mistake; the European Central Bank (ECB) has decisively been the game changer for how events are unfolding in Greece. The decision by the ECB to limit the emergency liquidity assistance provided to Greek financial institutions prompted the bank closures, which if they remain will have devastating and escalating effects on their economy. This is forcing the Greek government to reveal their hand, and their lack of experience in negotiations with the Troika is showing that they are as much concerned with remaining in power as they are with getting a bailout agreement. For a crisis that has been five years in the making, the introduction of capital controls has taken events to the new level.

Since Prime Minister Alex Tsipras blindsided his creditors last Friday in announcing a referendum on the terms of the proposed bailout, he has looked to avoid the vote he called for on multiple occasions. This is because a “yes” vote would ultimately cost him his job. In pre-empting that Greece would miss the 1.55 billion euro repayment to the IMF, the Greek Prime Minister in disregard to 5 months of discussions proposed terms for a brand new two year bail out agreement. This was quickly discarded by EU members.

Following being the first western nation to miss a payment to the IMF in their 70 year history, Tsipras conceded his demands to the creditors with only slight concessions for a discounted Value Added Tax for the Greek islands (a popular tourist destination) and less stringent pension reforms. Again the creditors didn’t blink. And it’s the leadership of Germany’s Angela Merkel, whether too stubborn or not, that has not shifted from the standpoint that they will await the result of the referendum as quite simply, the deadline was missed and the offer is now off the table.

The Greeks have backed themselves into a corner, and the results will range from financial hardship to devastating. Hardship as the result of continued recession in accepting the creditors demands for reforms to stay in the euro, and the potential devastation of a Greek exit, reintroduction of a new currency, and depreciation and rampant inflation. It currently remains unclear whether there is a third option and where a no vote prompts a new round of bargaining, and what will be the result.

By missing a payment to the IMF, they have technically not “defaulted.” Rating agency Standard and Poor’s justified this by saying the IMF is not a private creditor, thus the missed payment was not a credit altering event. Investors took another view, however, as the market for Two Year Greek Bonds over the past week have seen their yields surge to over 37 per cent. This then leading us to where we are today as the European Central Bank as well conceded they are lending money in what has become too risky of a scenario and limiting the liquidity assistance to Greek banks.

Capital Controls are very rarely removed as quickly as they are implemented. Iceland, hit by the financial crisis in 2008 is finally beginning plans to remove the imposed barriers 7 years later. In very simple terms, by imposing these limits to Greek account holders to withdraw only 60 euros a day, and not permitting transfers to financial institutions outside of Greece, it is an admission by policy makers that there is no longer confidence in their financial system.

There are a number of themes to draw on with the crisis in Greece, but the most astonishing is simply that a westernized economy now joins the ranks of Somalia and Zimbabwe in purposely missing a payment to the International Monetary Fund. Not only does this redraw the potential framework for the international lender of last resort should other economies face financial hardship, but demonstrates the course followed by populism and brinkmanship and the resulting fallout from bad to ugly.